Good points.
I only consider foam filling for convenience of my ownership. Not due to the conditions I operate the loader in.
You are correct, but I only put new centers in my wheels - I bought the set used and already mounted. Most of the damage and condition of the beads was pre-existing to my ownership. One or two already had tubes in them. And the wheels do fit the tires.
My thoughts are that if I can foam fill an existing tire for about the cost of a new tire, I might prefer that. From the looks of it, the foam will be a little more than a new tire, so it is not a straight forward decision.
My thoughts come from a high level of frustration I have experienced with these tires. I initially thought that installing tubes in them would eliminate many frustrations with maintaining good rim/bead seal - due to the previous bead damage. Well, the tubes where an expensive, time consuming mistake. I think I ended up buying a total of 8 or 10 tubes. Perhaps I did not choose the correct style tube, but at this point, I am done with them. Only one of the 3 tires still has a tube in it right now.
I posted this thread just after failing to get one of the tires to seat the beads and take air. I had tire mounting compound all over the place, tire sealer blowing out making a mess, and 3 different chain falls and come alongs around it squeezing the crap out of the damn thing. Plus, beating the ship out of it with a sledge, just trying to get the beads to seal - and failing.
ANYTHING was better than that.
Good news is that after setting the tire outside in the sun all day Monday, I tried one more time to get it to take air and got it done with a new tire chuck and just one of the come alongs.