I'm kind of guessing maybe a real cold start or two might cause this? I'm no pump expert but it looks to me like the plate that holds the feet may have lifted and allowed the feet coming around on the pressure side to "float", I can't think of any other reason why the piston feet would get chewed off on the outer edges like that, they kind of had to have been tilted, yeah?
If the pins are the same length by eyeball that should be good, might check the height installed, there's a mondo spring in the center of the cylinder they push on, it's rare but maybe the spring is broken or cocked.
If the pins are the same length by eyeball that should be good, might check the height installed, there's a mondo spring in the center of the cylinder they push on, it's rare but maybe the spring is broken or cocked.