Alright, you guys can say I told you so if that kind of thing makes you happy!
I cleaned around the pump very well. I CAREFULLY took the top cover off making sure I noted the position of the spring on the throttle linkage and the clevis in the governor arm. I replaced the o-rings on the throttle shaft and shutoff shaft. I had to scrape off the old gasket, it was a real mess and it made sense why it was leaking between the pump and cover. I plugged the holes in the pump before scraping to prevent any crap from getting in there. I got both sides nice and shiney and installed the new gasket. I put the cover back on EXACTLY how it came apart. I should have mentioned before I took it off I replaced the inline fuel filter/fuel filter/water separator. I tried to turn off the fuel shutoff coming out of the tank but unfortunately it didn't work, so when I replaced the inline I lost a lot of fuel. It didn't want to start so I followed the bleeding procedure but the manual lift pump doesn't work. I was able to get it primed though by cracking the bottom screw and using the ignition to turn over the motor, then did the top screw and it fired right up. After rebuilding the cover, I can not get it primed at the bottom screw. The first screw in the procedure, above the filter/ separator blows fuel fine, but nothing out of the bottom screw. It'd be so much easier if the manual pump worked!! Anyway, is there a common reason I'm overlooking for why I can't get it primed to the bottom of the pump?