Phil, thanks for the reply sorry that I took so long to answer, I was hoping that it was the pinion gear only but when I reached in the transmission and could move the bottom shaft I knew it was going to be more than just a simpe pinion which is probably broken also, that would be the bearing in the rear of the transmission out, at leaste hope so, once I remove the hoe, front end, rear wheels, rear end the the transmission sounds like a piece of cake, well at leaste labor is free, hope parts don't kill me, thanks for you help, nice to be able ask someone that know, will keep you posted and will take some pics for the fellow like me who have never done it before, take care, Joe G.