steel tracks or rubber tracks

[Bill Eh]

Thanks xkvator for your answer to my question on how much a KX41 would cost. I have another question that I hope someone can help me with. If I am buying a 6000 pound mini excavator should I pay the extra to get steel tracks? The steel cost about $1000 to $1200 more.

Bill

 

[digger242j]

The mini I spend much of my time on is a Kobelco 35. That's about an 8800 lb. machine.

Personally, I spend so much time running back and forth across pavement (both concrete and asphalt), that I can't imagine having anything but rubber tracks. I'll have to admit that I've spent almost no time on grass, so I can't say whether steel or rubber would work better there, but the rubber seems just fine on bare dirt as well.

 

[Cat420]

I found that the few mini excavators we have rented with rubber tracks tore the grass up very badly, much worse than steel. I would only get rubber if doing a substantial amount of work on pavement. In the dirt it would be steel all the way for me.

 

[will_gurt]

I have to agree with cat 420 here digger. Rubber tracks do seem to tear up the grass more.

 

[DR RPM]

You can reduce the grass tearing with the rubber tracks by lifting yourself up when turning and and plan your traveling accordingly to reduce your turns. :bash

 

[nobull1]

I have a opinion on rubber tracks which you can read at this link. Realize that this is only my opinion, and I don't claim to be right. Any questions feel free to ask.rubber tracks

 

[Steve Frazier]

nobull1, feel free to reprint you opinion here!!

 

[Jimothy]

Way easier to fix grass then to fix concrete or asphalt or what ever else that steel can tear up if the machine is small enough we throw rubber pads on the tracks because if we need to jump a curb or do who knows what it’s much easier to fix grass.

that being said we’ve been to places where ur not aloud to damage anything… just don’t go there lol