Bandit,
Remember this is just my opinion and do not want to offend anybody, but this is what works best for me and I am sure that the standpipe works best for lowboy. Have a good day and best of luck
No offense taken at all d6. It's what works for you, then keep doing it. I just had 2 nightmare experiences with spillway inverts in the past, and again I prefer to have a future plan to drain the pond for whatever reason with a mechanical device, rather than to have to dig it all up with a machine.
All the ones I've done have had more than a few trees around as I recall, but you have to devise a good solid fastening system that holds your pipe in place, and it's a little bit of a dicipline thing to maintain it periodically too.
Standpipes are a standard practice even in our state engineered plans.
I just finished another pond project I was working on that was NY State Dept. of Environmental Conservation permitted, and was taken to the extreme by them. They made us drain the pond (about an acre) totally, install $160K dollars worth of sheet piling at the old dam location, remove the perfectly fine concrete dam and rebuild an earthen dam. In addition to that, a 36"X36" square concrete drainage basin, into a 30" concrete pipe out 200 feet to a discharge point, with a 15" mallable iron gate valve down inside the basin to "adjust" flow. The valve was $2,500.00 alone.
Then, in addition to that, an "Overflow Swale" measuring 20 feet wide by 100' long, 2 on 1 sloped banks with fabric, 3" of 3/4" stone, and 14" of 6" rip rap on that. This swale will never see a drop of water in it's life with the basin and valve assembly there, but it's called C.Y.A.
Perfect example of when the DEC gets involved.
Again, I and many other contractors in this region use standpipes solely because fresh fill in an earthen dam, unless you're able to compact it well, have favorable material in the first place to work with, and let it set and "bake" without any added moisture till it's set, is a gamble the higher the water level behind it is.
If it's only a small, subtle overflowage going somewhere, there can be some exceptions, but again, it could be a lifetime babysitting venture if not engineered properly.:thumbsup