And some guy probably unloaded that machine at an auction thinking it was going to need an expensive transmission overhaul.
Very likely the case. This is part of the auction game. As I recall, we got this machine rather cheap, so that seems like a reasonable explanation. The previous owner may not have had anyone capable of troubleshooting it or chose not to get someone who could, or perhaps if someone did have a look, either didn't find it or just told the guy it needed a new trans. Probably never know, but this was a zero parts cost fix, other than the F-N-R switch which did have some burned contacts that gave it erratic upshifts in forward, but that cost less than a hundred bucks and fixed what had been more of a nuisance than anything. The no reverse problem was not affected by that part replacement anyway. This one was nearly pure labor, and not really that much time.
skata The thing about fora in general is that when someone posts up a problem and everyone tries to help, one of the worst things (to me) is that the readers, for possibly years in the future, never know the results. Was it fixed? Which suggestion was the correct solution? How does the story end? I used to lurk a lot of fora on different topics, and when I searched for previously presented problems, finding hanging threads was always frustrating to me. Even if the story didn't have a happy ending, at least the readers should know what happened. Maybe the machine burned to the ground....but we'd never know unless it was a closed thread. I promise to try and never leave an open thread here, although it may happen despite my efforts. I'm only human, and have typically a dozen running projects, some spread out a good bit, time-wise. It's not like a shop where I can just start a repair and not do much else until that one is complete. I jump around a lot, and some of it is not even heavy machinery related. I worked on a cardboard baler last week. And not all are presented here as trouble assistance pleas, but there is a lot to keep up with and my memory isn't what it used to be.
But you're most welcome.