Kxnate
Well-Known Member
They are few and far between. Some will have the problem sure. You also need to remember what % of owners are online posting about issues, and how many of the people with problems helped caused them. But some gas engines will only make 100k-120k before replacement. Unless you are incredibly unlucky or don't look after it the diesel will last at least 250k before needing much if anything and that's still very low compared to how long most of them go. Even with a $10k repair, that diesel will be a lower operating cost when you factor in purchase, interest, maintenance, fuel, and resale compared to a hemi if you are towing/hauling regularly. Heck empty the diesel will get way better mileage.
Remember suladas, I have owned a diesel for 12 years now, my dad has owned one for 11. I am not diesel ignorant or inexperienced. I have an 05 5.9 6 SPD manual. Best hand calculated mileage empty ever in the 12 years I've owned it is 16.75mpg. My dad has a 2010 6.7 cummins 6spd auto, est he's seen out of his empty is around 17. I don't know if we get **** fuel in Montana or what, but we never see anywhere close to the mileages people claim to get out of these cummins. So no, they won't get way better mileage empty.
As far as longevity, a gas is no different than a diesel in that alot depends on how it is taken care of and driven. My dad ran a 2002 Chevy with a 6.0 for his job to over 300000 miles on the original engine. My grandfather had a pilot car service in the 90's and ran Dodge Dakotas with 318's to over 400000 miles on original engines before getting.new ones.
As far as the rarity of the CP4 pump failures.....umm ford and gm have been having problems with them for years and now cummins gets the bright idea to start using them. The dealer I ordered my truck from (in a small town of about 20k people) has already had 2 CP4 failures through their shop.
You are obviously a diesel fan and that's fine, but they aren't the be all end all for everyone. And I am not uneducated in the way of the diesel.
Last edited: