DerelictTexture
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2012
- Messages
- 256
- Location
- Vancouver BC
- Occupation
- Trying tto figure out what to do when I grow up
The ever continuing story of Sam Fitzpatricks's death at the Toba/Montrose hydro power project.
Kiewit was fined 250,000 dollars for being negligent in the handling and coordination of the safety programs, lack of proper rock scaling and poor supervision of workers in a dangerous environment.
Kiewit appealed the fine, and lost. They appealed a 2nd time and Sam's dad fought back through the Workers Advisory office. The second appeal went to a tribunal panel.
On March 16/2013, the panel used these words to describe the company .... "wantonly reckless, recklessly negligent and guilty of gross negligence"
However...despite the excellent work of the lead WorkSafe investigator, and strong and clear language used to describe the situation at the Toba site....the panel could not see enough evidence to prove that the rock that rolled down the hill and killed Sam, was actually generated by the actions of the project.
Not one, but two excavators were working above the hand drillers, on a 35% slope...in clear violation of the 12 hr old ban on machines working above other crews.
The tribunal panel ( WCAT ) reduced the fine from 250,000 dollars....down to less than 100,000 dollars ( 5 minutes of income for a 10 billion dollar a year company )
Brian Fitzpatrick has hired a lawyer to work on a judicial review to try and introduce new evidence, and get the issue of the rock cleared up.
Here is the WCB report...it's long and sometimes hard to follow...but worth your time. There is a lot to learn from this incident. ( I refuse to call it an "accident" )
http://thetyee.ca/Documents/2013/04/07/Toba Inlet Worksafe Report.pdf
Here is an excellent TV show that documented some of the activities at the Toba project. Sam and his brother Arlen are featured.
Mega Builders: Peak Power http://ustre.am/:1bHs2
This week, Brian and I will be learning about "crowdfunding" as a way to pay for his legal fees. Brian is not suing anyone....just looking for justice and the right answer.
Kiewit was fined 250,000 dollars for being negligent in the handling and coordination of the safety programs, lack of proper rock scaling and poor supervision of workers in a dangerous environment.
Kiewit appealed the fine, and lost. They appealed a 2nd time and Sam's dad fought back through the Workers Advisory office. The second appeal went to a tribunal panel.
On March 16/2013, the panel used these words to describe the company .... "wantonly reckless, recklessly negligent and guilty of gross negligence"
However...despite the excellent work of the lead WorkSafe investigator, and strong and clear language used to describe the situation at the Toba site....the panel could not see enough evidence to prove that the rock that rolled down the hill and killed Sam, was actually generated by the actions of the project.
Not one, but two excavators were working above the hand drillers, on a 35% slope...in clear violation of the 12 hr old ban on machines working above other crews.
The tribunal panel ( WCAT ) reduced the fine from 250,000 dollars....down to less than 100,000 dollars ( 5 minutes of income for a 10 billion dollar a year company )
Brian Fitzpatrick has hired a lawyer to work on a judicial review to try and introduce new evidence, and get the issue of the rock cleared up.
Here is the WCB report...it's long and sometimes hard to follow...but worth your time. There is a lot to learn from this incident. ( I refuse to call it an "accident" )
http://thetyee.ca/Documents/2013/04/07/Toba Inlet Worksafe Report.pdf
Here is an excellent TV show that documented some of the activities at the Toba project. Sam and his brother Arlen are featured.
Mega Builders: Peak Power http://ustre.am/:1bHs2
This week, Brian and I will be learning about "crowdfunding" as a way to pay for his legal fees. Brian is not suing anyone....just looking for justice and the right answer.