vermontfarmer
New Member
Hello,
I've been reading the forum but this is my first post. My father in law is out west hand felling trees currently at a fire in Washington was at the bootleg fire before that. When fire season is over he wants to buy an excavator. Probably in the 20k ton range maybe could go bigger, we can borrow a little kubota for small jobs and my wife and I are planning on splitting the cost with him. He has some ponds and ditches and general farm stuff he would like to use it for.
Our farm is 312 acres mostly wooded, a bit rocky and some decent slopes that we have been converting to silvopasture for that past few years. Right now we cut by hand and pull out firewood and market logs with a skidder. We have been looking at add a mulcher into the mix to speed up clearing smaller trees and processing the tops faster. As well and clearing some larger branches of trees we are leaving. We also have some road/trail clearing and building to do. We will still be felling larger trees with our chainsaws. We have a new barn foundation to dig, some ditch work, frost free lines trenches.
I've been reading about how hard mulch heads are on CTL's and how stand alone track machines stand up better. But we really can afford a one purpose machine. We may do a few jobs off the farm with the mulcher to help with payments but most of them would be smaller jobs with selective cutting. We do need a new skid steer/CTL for our normal farm chores like heavy wrapped bales, scrapping bedding etc. But would hate to really shorten its life running a mulch head if an excavator option is just as good or better.
Are the mulching heads also really rough on excavators?
I'm thinking it would be better for looking our for rocks or other things sitting up higher in the excavator.
I would expect it to be able to clear less acreage per day than a purpose built machine, but is there a big difference in what a CTL vs and Excavator can do.
Are there better manufacturers for running a mulch head then others
I'm also not exactly sure what our price point will be. It depends on how long he stays out there and how much of a tax write off he wants.
I've been reading the forum but this is my first post. My father in law is out west hand felling trees currently at a fire in Washington was at the bootleg fire before that. When fire season is over he wants to buy an excavator. Probably in the 20k ton range maybe could go bigger, we can borrow a little kubota for small jobs and my wife and I are planning on splitting the cost with him. He has some ponds and ditches and general farm stuff he would like to use it for.
Our farm is 312 acres mostly wooded, a bit rocky and some decent slopes that we have been converting to silvopasture for that past few years. Right now we cut by hand and pull out firewood and market logs with a skidder. We have been looking at add a mulcher into the mix to speed up clearing smaller trees and processing the tops faster. As well and clearing some larger branches of trees we are leaving. We also have some road/trail clearing and building to do. We will still be felling larger trees with our chainsaws. We have a new barn foundation to dig, some ditch work, frost free lines trenches.
I've been reading about how hard mulch heads are on CTL's and how stand alone track machines stand up better. But we really can afford a one purpose machine. We may do a few jobs off the farm with the mulcher to help with payments but most of them would be smaller jobs with selective cutting. We do need a new skid steer/CTL for our normal farm chores like heavy wrapped bales, scrapping bedding etc. But would hate to really shorten its life running a mulch head if an excavator option is just as good or better.
Are the mulching heads also really rough on excavators?
I'm thinking it would be better for looking our for rocks or other things sitting up higher in the excavator.
I would expect it to be able to clear less acreage per day than a purpose built machine, but is there a big difference in what a CTL vs and Excavator can do.
Are there better manufacturers for running a mulch head then others
I'm also not exactly sure what our price point will be. It depends on how long he stays out there and how much of a tax write off he wants.