I am interested in knowing more about the 160 you haul with the same trailer. Around here, excavators are commonly equipped with some or all of the following: quick couplers, hydraulic link thumbs, long sticks, long and wide undercarriage, catwalks, circle guarding, hardened rear doors, extra counterweight, etc.. With a base weight of 36,000 to 39,000 lb (depending on make and series), a fully equipped 160 can be over 40,000 lbs pretty easily. In Washington we are only allowed 34,000 lbs on a set of tandem duals with normal axle spacing. I can't recall seeing anyone local hauling a 150-160 size excavator on anything less than a three axle trailer in years. Back in the day before every town and county around here had commercial vehicle enforcement officers, you might see a 150-160 on a two axle trailer, but the trailer would typically be a tilt deck with the low profile 22.5 rubber. Does VA allow more weight on the trailer axles? If so, could you be exceeding the load limit on your tires (looks to be approx 4500 lbs/tire) if you have the 215/75 R17.5 tires that Eager Beaver specs for that trailer? Switching to the 235/75 R17.5 would give you quite a bit more capacity, if that is an option. I know you said that you haven't had problems hauling the 160 the last 5 years, but could it be that you have been lucky?