Need help deciding on a truck.
So we've started the downsizing process, and some new oppurtunity lies on the horizon. Its a little bit scary, but exciting at the same time. I will go into more detail later on after things are more final. The Mack left yesterday, it was bought back by the dealer we bought it from, it was definitely bitter sweet. I would have loved to keep it but a person can only do so much. It makes more sense for me to be on iron and hire out trucking, then for me to try and do both. I am keeping a single axle to move equipment and for short hauls, I will have the quarry deliver to a stockpile location and short haul to jobs from there. It has proved to be a succesful method for us in the past. So the decision is down to one of 2 trucks.
The GMC 7500:
We are the only owner
33K GVW
3116 cat 250HP
RT6613 road ranger
10' box with air gate and elec. tarp
pintle with air and elec.
69,000 original miles
The Ford L9000:
We are the 3rd owner, first was ryder (tractor) then an older fellow who turned it into a dump and ran it for a paving company. He was a stickler on maintenace and it shows, its a cream puff. (does smoke at low idle, previous owner had fuel turned up I suspect this is the source)
35KGVW
L10 Cummins 280HP
10 speed road ranger.
10'HD box with air gate (3 shoots) and elec. tarp
has air and elec. to rear, needs a good pintle plate.
275,000 miles
Im torn here, I know the better truck for me is the Ford, but I know everything that has ever been done to the GMC. The 3116 is basically obsolote so parts/rebuild could cost more than the truck is worth, plus its smaller than the duramax in my dads truck. Its only like 6.9 liter and 600 ft/lbs torque, not really enough for my area, it has always done OK, but it works hard.
The L10 is making a lot more torque, nearly double. Parts and rebuild are more readily available and it has a lot better reputation. I am a little concerned about the smoke but the previous owner had the fuel turned up for more power, so Im hoping that its just getting more fuel than it can burn. For instance, coming down a 12% grade loaded, I slow down and it starts to blow white smoke pretty good. After leaving the stop sign at the bottom the smoke starts to clear up and eventually disappears when you start to pull. I am calling a diesel shop in the morning about getting it in for service and getting it looked at.
So given this info, which truck is the best option? I was thinking the GMC but now Im leaning toward the Ford. For hauling 8-10 ton in the hills and moving the 110 on the trailer I think the L10 is going to be a lot better.
Thanks for the input!