Hey guys,
New to the forum, but glad to be here. Anyway, I had the same problem you were having with the Gehl RS8-44 with the Deere 4045 up here in Sitka, AK. Cranks til the cows come home, no smoke, no start. The owner of the machine called our shop and asked for some assistance, so we went to check it out. When I first arrived (a month ago now), we had electrical issues in the cab, fuse block area. We had a blown relay, and when we replaced that, we were popping the fuse for the ignition switch. Finally got that issue straight (who ever cobbled the wiring together in this before us... what a nightmare). Anyway, once we resolved that issue we were able to connect to the JD Service Advisor and pull up some codes. We were getting codes for the analog throttle being out of range. We took the TPS off of the throttle pedal, cleaned it up, and clocked it so that we were getting the proper voltage readings on the service advisor. Codes had cleared, but we still had all crank and no run.
Now when I tell you we had issue after issue, I mean it. We had incorrect voltage readings on just about everything we tested for the first week or so, the service advisor was hit or miss on every window we tried to open. Everything pointed to the ECU. We replaced it with a "known-good" ECU like Deere says to. Finally got the darn thing able to open up some trim pages, and we tried shutting off some of the "shutdowns" programmed into the ECU. Still didn't run.
Now, we're communicating with some guys back in Seattle about different things. We had chased wires, fuses, fuel lines, filters, everything you guys have described. They sent us up a new Standyne DE-10 pump, and we timed it AS THE BOOK said, and guess what, it still didn't run.
Somewhere along the line, we went to pump up the transfer pump by hand, and it was just leaking fuel out of the weep hole, suggesting the diaphragm was bad. So we replaced that. Still no fire.
So today, we started grabbing at straws. Pulled valve cover, CHECKED VALVES AT TDC and put the pin in the flywheel like Deere asked. Rotated engine 360* to get the rest of the valves. Everything checked out alright. Went to crank the engine just for giggles, and when we went back to look over some more stuff, we saw 1/8" of clearance under both #1 cylinder valves... what the heck? We used the timing pin just like they asked! But wait... does that fricken pin go into the flywheel at more than one spot? SURE DOES. Ours went in, in 8 different positions along a full rotation of the crank. YOU HAVE TO BE KIDDING ME!
What does that mean? We pulled the injector from the #1 cylinder and used a small piece of gas welding rod to really see when #1 was at TDC. Sure enough, way off on the valves. So we went to re-adjust. INT and EXH on #1, INT on #2, and EXH on #3 (I believe that's the right order off the top of my head.) But what that also means is that
IF THE TIMING PIN GOES IN THE FLYWHEEL, IT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE ENGINE IS ON THE RIGHT STROKE!!! WHICH IN TURN, CAN ALTER THE TIMING ON THE INJECTION PUMP!
We pulled out the plug for the timing pin in the injection pump and sure enough, it was out of time. We pulled the gear off, took the pump out (meanwhile, the flywheel timing pin is still in the engine), and put the timing pin in the injection pump. Put everything back in torqued the gear, hooked the lines back up, and cranked but still wouldn't start. We cracked the lines loose at the injectors to bleed the air out, got fuel at all four lines, tightened them and WALLAH!!! Fire in the hole!
I'm sorry for the novel, but after hearing about so many people fight with this miserable collaboration of parts and manufacturer's, I just hoped that maybe this would help someone out. The moral of the story is, make sure that #1 is at the top of its stroke and the valves are loose before you assume the timing pin in the flywheel is in the right position, and then pin the pump. I have no idea why there were 8 holes in the flywheel, and I would hope that if they were from where they drilled for balancing, that they wouldn't fall in the same groove as the hole for the timing pin. Either way, it sure jerked us around a lot, 3 weeks of chasing ghosts and we finally got an answer.
Best of luck to you guys and if there's anything I can help you with, let me know and I'll do my best.