Not a fan...
So what do you guys think about using stop leak additives in modern motors?
I have a Cummins M11 that is weeping from under the plate on the right hand side of the block.
Probably only a $2 gasket but would require extensive surgery to get at.
Not a fan...
Me neither. The best way of fixing a coolant leak IMHO is a proper repair job using the correct seals and/or gaskets. I've always considered all these chemical leak stoppers as a bodge, and heard some fair horror stories about what they do to the inside of cooling systems. Although to be fair I haven't seen it for myself - wait a minute, that's possibly 'cos I don't use them, duuuuuuuuuh.
I'd love to see things from your perspective but unfortunately I find it impossible to get my head that far up my a$$.
Nige, we just had to replace the whole engine in our truck b/c of some bonehead using stop leak in it. Quick fixes arent.
Stop leak is the devil! I'm not sure about the core sizes on heavy equip/trucks. But on passenger vehicles I've seen rads clogged with that garbage. Blue devil additive is the only stuff I've seen not destroy the system. Works well in slight combustion chamber leaks.
had a fellow tell me to put a couple of eggs and pepper in the coolant system if you spring a leak to get yourself outter trouble well after i stopped laughing at him i said i wouldn`t be hungry if i sprung a radiator leak .
well 6 months later we were irrigating and the pump motor sprung a water leak and i did not want to stop from watering till i finished the paddock so with the biggest smile on me face i thought about the egg and pepper trick.
well , off i go and raids mums fridge of some eggs and find the pepper pot , mum looks a me and i tell her not to ask .
down i go take the cap off cracks the egg in and i think the blood egg instantly went hard boiled halve way in .
find a screw driver and poke it all in , now i`m laughing at myself thinking what the flam`n heck are you doing .
ended up putting three eggs in and a good handfull of pepper , well here i am watching the radiator still leaking water and looking at boiled eggs sitting in the top radiator tank and again thinking what am i doing , you idiot .
off i go and see how long before the next change was due so i could shut the pump down and do what should have been done in the first place . about an hour later i gets back to this motor and bugger me it had taken up and the radiator is still full of water with no sign of eggs floating around , ended up finishing the watering out and doing the next time around two because i forgot about getting it fixed .
So fellows remember eggs and pepper will get you outter trouble in a pinch
I've heard that yarn before as well, Greeniron, but always thought it was an old wifes tale.
You may have seen an Aust. made product called Scotts Superior Radiator Sealer.
I have used it before in much older motors with good results and no ill effects, but am hesitant to use anything in this one, because of the reasons mentioned above and also because it is the most expensive motor I own.
Yeh, but you don`t have to put both the egg and the pepper in, a handfull of pepper or just a couple of egg whites will suffice.
Well Im a fan of stopleak. Here in the cold climate's salt is used on our roadways yeararound... in the winter for ice control, summer for dust control. The fins on our radiators take a severe beating. Salt can make little pinholes in your radiator and the stopleak fix's them. I have some radiators with lots of fins eaten off by the salt but yet still function properly year round. Where the leak is from seal's and gaskets, by all means replace it properly,,,, but THERE is a time and place for everything,,,,, just sayin,
I treat everybody the same...... I give em all grief.
I am not a big fan of using any of them , but as has been said, they are good if you're in a pinch. If you use them, when you do make the repair, the entire cooling system needs to be flushed and back flushed. Years back, there was a truck being used on a jobsite . It had a 573 Gasser that had a external crack in one of the heads. Bars Leak was used in that for the duration of the job. It did plug the leak for a week or so with each new application. Not sure what it did to the rest of the cooling system though.
I will second K-seal. It has worked wonders on my landrover with no ill affects. It did over 100,000 miles on it and still going strong untill it got written off in a roll over. The only thing to remember is to add fresh every time you change the water.
I used it on my old Bronco. It worked.
I have also seen the mess it makes when it didnt work and more and more was added.
go to conklin.com i use there stop leak. but stop leak only stops the leak for a short time